Is Milky Spore an Effective Japanese Beetle Control? Will it Protect Your Lawn from Grub Damage?
Milky Spore is a product that contains the spores of a naturally
occurring soil bacterium. When these spores are eaten by a Japanese
beetle grub they cause a Disease called Milky disease that slowly kills
Milky disease has proven to be an effective biological
control of Japanese beetles grubs. However, it has been used with
mixed results - as expected with any biological control. Its had a
successful history of reducing beetle populations in certain parts of
the eastern United States, especially when used in community-wide
treatment programs. On the other hand, there has not been enough
research conducted to understand how well it works. The land grant
universities that have run trials have come to the same conclusion -
commercial applications of Bacillus popilliae spores offer very little benefit and are not worth the expense.
So...is it worth buying and applying to your lawn?
It depends on where you live, if you actually have Japanese beetle grubs in your lawn and you are willing to gamble a few bucks - about $10 to $14 per 1000 ft2 - buying and applying the spores with the aim of protecting your lawn from Japanese beetle grubs.
Do you live where Japanese beetles are a problem? Japanese beetles have been a major problem in the eastern states and have been migrating into the Midwest.
Milky Spore is not effective in cooler northern climates - the spores need soil temperatures to be above 70° F for several months.
Another fact to consider: Japanese beetle grubs rarely reach the damage threshold of 10 grubs per ft2. A healthy lawn will recover quickly from grub feeding without showing any signs of damage.
Milky Spore Facts
The bacterium Bacillus popilliae (recently renamed Paenibacillus popilliae) has little or no effect on the other grubs that feed on grass roots. Different species of white grubs can be present in the same areas and at the same time as Japanese beetle grubs.
It is not harmful to beneficial insects, birds, bees, pets, humans or any other organism.
Milky Spore has been used to combat Japanese beetles since the 1940s and is one of the first biological insect controls to be released in the United States.
Birds, skunks or other animals eating grubs can spread the spores - they remain viable through their digestive tracts.
Called Milky disease because the grub's normally clear blood turns milky white.
The spores multiply within infected grubs and this is the only way the disease spreads.
Spores can infect grubs in all three larval stages (larval stages are usually called instars). After infected, the grubs will live and continue to feed several weeks but will never transform to the next larval stage and will not pupate or develop into adult beetles.
Milky disease will not totally eradicate a population of grubs but it will reduce them below the damage threshold (10 grubs per ft2).
The disease is capable of suppressing a population of grubs feeding on your lawn but will not kill adult beetles.
Adults are strong fliers and will travel 5 miles to find a good place to eat and reproduce. If you treat your lawn with the ambition of stopping Japanese beetle adults from eating your garden plants - you will be disappointed. They will just fly in from your neighbors yard.
A community-wide program has to be used to reduce the populations of adult beetles.
Tip: Those Japanese beetle pheromone traps will attract beetles to your property - more beetles than they will actually catch. Only use these if you have a lot of acreage and hang them on the outskirts - as far as you can get them from your garden and landscape plants.
How Milky Spore Works
The spores of a treated area are washed into the soil where they
stick to soil particles, roots and organic matter near the soil surface
and remain viable for several years. When a grub feeding in the area
eats spores, the ingested spores germinate in its gut and the bacteria
infect and kill the grub. As the dead grub decays, it releases a couple
billion new spores back into the soil - spreading the disease. Other
grubs feeding in the area are then infected and continue to spread the
disease. Over time - 2 to 5 years - the spores have the potential to
completely saturate a treated soil with the ability to suppress a grub
population several years.
Mixed Results and Debate
As with all biological controls - sometimes it works and sometimes it
doesn't. Biological controls are very dependent on environmental
factors. The spores need to remain viable, be eaten by the grubs and
then rely upon infected grubs moving to another area to spread more
There is a lot of debate about how effective Milky Spore
actually is. Environmental conditions, misapplications or just being
impatient can be blamed for some of the failures. Grubs move slowly
through the soil and the spores do not move by themselves, so it can
take 2 to 5 years for the spores to be dispersed throughout the soil by
infected grubs. There is also concerns that the Japanese beetle grubs
might be developing resistance to Milky Spore disease.
Control Success Depends On:
Temperatures over 70° F are required for rapid buildup of spores - Milky Spore will not be effective in northern climates where soil temperatures are under 70° F most of the year.
Milky Spore is a very passive control method, the bacterium is not mobile in the soil and the grubs need to go where the spores are and then eat them.
The goal of using Milky Spore is to keep the population levels below the damage threshold - below 10 grubs per ft2. Milky disease will not completely eradicate a grub population.
Best time to apply is in August - so it is in the soil where the newly hatching grubs are feeding. However, it can be applied whenever the soil is not frozen.
Patience, it might take several years for the spores to spread to high enough levels (2 - 5 years).
A high population of grubs is required to spread the spores quickly. The more grubs in your lawn that get infected, the faster the spores will spread throughout the soil.
How to Apply Milky Spore
Here's a good application demonstration - with a couple of mistakes...
calls it a "solution to grub and Japanese beetle control" and makes a
very optimistic claim of "many grub free and Japanese beetle free