Comparing Organic Lawn Fertilizer with Chemical Fertilizers

Last updated: 5 March 2024

Are natural organic fertilizers safer than chemical fertilizers? Are they better for your lawn, family and the environment?

Ideally, soils will support plant life – but this is not usually the case. We fertilize because soils lack the elements to support plant growth. Natural organic fertilizer, manufactured organic and chemical fertilizers all serve the same purpose – to provide nutrients needed by plants to sustain healthy growth.

There is a lot of debate and confusion over the best type of lawn fertilizer. The type you use makes no difference to your grass. All types have advantages and disadvantages and when properly used are safe for lawns, and the environment and involve few risks to humans or other animals. To be used by grass, all nutrients in fertilizers – no matter the source – must be broken down into the same chemical form (listed in the table below).

Organic vs. Chemical Fertilizers

Fertilizer becomes a pollutant when it is misapplied or overapplied – it does not matter if the product is natural organic or synthetic. Take care to use fertilizers according to their labels and instructions. Proper rate and timing are important as well as basing lawn nutrient requirements on a reliable soil test. Protect our water sources! Avoid getting fertilizer on sidewalks, driveways and roads where it can wash into storm drains and then into streams, lakes and rivers.

There are 16 essential elements needed by plants to grow (see the table below). Carbon, hydrogen and oxygen are available to plants from air and water. The other 13 elements are supplied to the plants from the soil. Fertilizers supplement the soil with these needed nutrients.

The 13 mineral elements found in soils are grouped according to amounts found within plants – macronutrients, secondary nutrients and micronutrients. Nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) – the macronutrients – are the three main nutrients in fertilizer and needed by plants the most. The secondary and micronutrients are essential but in very small amounts.

**16 Elements Essential For Plant Growth**
Element	Symbol	Form Available to Plants
Source: Air and Water
Carbon	C		CO₂
Oxygen	O		O₂ and H₂0
Hydrogen	H		H₂O
Source: Soil – Macronutrients
Nitrogen	N	Nitrate & Ammonium	NO₃^–, NH₄⁺
Phosphorus	P	Phosphate	H₂PO₄^–
Potassium	K	Potassium	K⁺
Source: Soil – Secondary Nutrients
Calcium	Ca	Calcium	Ca⁺⁺
Sulfur	S	Sulfate	SO₄⁼
Magnesium	Mg	Magnesium	Mg⁺⁺
Source: Soil – Micronutrients
Manganese	Mn	Manganese	Mn⁺⁺
Zinc	Zn	Zinc	Zn⁺⁺
Boron	B	Borate	H₂BO₃^–
Copper	Cu	Copper	Cu⁺⁺
Iron	Fe	Iron	Fe⁺⁺⁺
Molybdenum	Mo	Molybdate	MoO₄⁼
Chlorine	Cl	Cloride	Cl^–

There are hundreds of companies that claim their products will improve your soil and make your lawn more vigorous and healthier than their competitor’s brand. So how do you choose the best lawn fertilizer?

Nutrient release rate and cost of actual nutrients per pound are important factors to consider.

Chemical fertilizers with fast nutrient release rates provide nutrients in forms that are highly soluble and available to your lawn. These products must be used carefully. They will stimulate quick growth, must be applied at low rates and frequently, will burn your grass when over applied and are likely to leach nutrients into groundwater.

Natural organic fertilizers release nutrients slowly. As the soil microorganisms decompose the organic matter, the nutrients are converted into the chemical forms that are available to plants. Higher application rates may be applied, they have a low burn potential and will last longer.

Chemical fertilizers are also available in slow-release formulations that release nutrients by water penetration, weathering or microbial action.

Since the purpose of fertilizing is to provide essential nutrients to assist plant growth, it makes sense to consider the cost of the actual nutrients in the product you are purchasing.

Fertilizer Analysis – the concentration of nutrients by percent – is printed prominently on the product label. The analysis is always printed in a three-number sequence indicating the amounts of N – P – K. An example is 23-3-6, which indicates 23% Nitrogen, Phosphorus equivalent to 3% P₂O₅, and Potassium equivalent to 6% K₂O.

Spreading Organic Fertilizer

Ultimately it is up to you to decide what is best for your lawn based on the advantages and disadvantages of each.

What we cover

Want to know what your lawn needs and when to apply it?

Let the turfgrass experts on Sunday take care of the technical stuff.

Have you heard about the Sunday Smart Lawn Plan? It’s simple, do-it-yourself natural lawn care that’s customized to your soil, climate, and lawn. Delivered to you right when you need it. You apply the nutrient packets with the included hose-end sprayer…simple, professional results!

Sunday’s plant and soil nutrient products are made from food waste, seaweed, and molasses. The natural additives stimulate plant growth and activate soil life.

This is Super Environmentally Friendly lawn care!

Advantages of Natural Organic Fertilizers

They are made from renewable resources and recycled materials.
Add organic matter to the soil – improving the physical nature of the soil.
Feed beneficial soil microbes, increasing their activity.
Slow nutrient release rate – high application rates may be applied that will last longer than chemical fertilizers…meaning fewer applications per year.
Less nutrient loss from poorly timed applications.
Very low potential to cause salt damage – “burn”.
Contains micronutrients.

Disadvantages of Natural Organic Fertilizers

Relatively low concentrations of actual nutrients – low nutrient analysis compared to synthetic products.
Require larger volumes of product per application
They are expensive – pound for pound of actual nutrients are higher than synthetic products.
Depend on warm temperatures and soil microbe activity to work – slow response in cool soils.
Exact content of nutrients is often unknown.
Homeowners often misjudge application rates due to the large volume needed…meaning they don’t spread enough product.
Composts and manure often contain weed seeds.
Organic residues that have a low nitrogen content can cause nitrogen deficiencies in plants as microorganisms decompose the organic compounds.

Advantages of Manufactured Organic and Chemical Fertilizers

Less expensive than natural organic products.
Labeled with the specific amount of nutrients contained in the package – easy to calculate proper rates.
Contain higher nutrient concentrations – meaning less product required to handle and apply.
Spreads easily in liquid or dry forms.
Fast-release nutrients available to plants in any weather.
Slow-release formulations are available (For example – sulfur-coated urea & IBDU).
Allow turfgrass managers to spoon-feed precise doses of nutrients that can be custom-made for your requirements.

Disadvantages of Manufactured Organic and Chemical fertilizers

They are normally made from petroleum or natural gas – some are made from naturally occurring mineral deposits.
Fast-release nutrients are prone to leaching and have a high burn potential.
Fast-release chemical fertilizers have a high potential to leach nutrients into ground waters.
Chemical fertilizers require more applications per year than organic fertilizers.

Fertilizer Calculators

Determine how much fertilizer is needed to cover your lawn.

Calculate the cost of nitrogen per pound. This is helpful when comparing fertilizer products by the actual cost of nitrogen contained in the product.

Comparing Organic Lawn Fertilizer with Chemical Fertilizers

Want to know what your lawn needs and when to apply it?

Fertilizer Calculators

You might like these natural lawn care tips:

Organic Lawn Fertilizer | Benefits of Natural Fertilizers

Vinegar Weed Killer vs Roundup

Corn Gluten Meal – Natural Weed and Feed for Lawns